Originally Posted by
Rogues Gallery
Lets give you some facts.
Monie coached Parramatta to their Premiership, true they had the likes of Sterling, Kenny, Price etc etc.
He then came to Wigan and took over a very good team and won Championships, Challenge Cups, World Club comps etc etc.
When he came back to Wigan in 1998 he didn't have that same quality of squad but went on to win the first Grand Final, a coincidence?
McGuire, came to Wigan as an unknown and with just one signing, Paul Deacon who most on here didn't rate, finished in 1st place and Grand Final winners.
The year after he coached Wigan to win the Challenge Cup Final.
He then went to South Sydney and within a three years coached them to their 1st Premiership in over 40 years, won the Aukland 9's and World Club Challenge.
A coincidence?
Both were top class coaches and worth of consideration for greatest coach. IMO.