You’re right, it’s a make or break season for Holbrook as well as Richardson. Another season without a semi final win then questions should be asked about Holbrook’s future and if Richardson performs as poorly as last season then we should be looking for a new scrum half. Hopefully that won’t be the case. Fages did come on off the bench in the first semi and was terrible, threw a forward pass at a time when we had Catalans on the back foot, blew another try and Moa walked through him to score. Why people think Fages is the answer I don’t know. He’s never been good enough and never will be. Also, a half with the ability to control a game would have made a huge difference in both games.